Daily Kos: This Georgia death row prisoner deserves clemency

This week, Georgia issued a warrant to execute Warren Lee Hill Jr., a death-row inmate convicted of murder, who has an I.Q. of 70. The Georgia Board of Pardons and Paroles is the fail-safe in the state’s criminal justice system, with a mandate to exercise mercy when the court system has failed to come to a just result. That is clearly true in this case. The trial judge found that Mr. Hill was mentally retarded by applying the fairer “preponderance of the evidence” standard in determining his mental impairment.

The State Supreme Court, however, ruled that Mr. Hill had to prove his mental retardation beyond a reasonable doubt. The dissent rightly argued that applying the tougher standard is unconstitutional because it imposes too high a risk that a court’s conclusion will be wrong. The dissent relied on the United States Supreme Court holding that it is unconstitutional to require a defendant to prove that he is incompetent to stand trial by any standard higher than a preponderance of the evidence.

via Daily Kos: This Georgia death row prisoner deserves clemency.

One comment

  1. nonviolentconflict · ·

    Reblogged this on NonviolentConflict.

ΝΕΑ ΧΩΡΙΣ ΦΙΛΤΡΟ ΦΕΛΛΟΥ

Νέα και Παράξενα-Σελίδες εναλλακτικής πληροφόρησης και ειδήσεων-alternative informations

Free Collective

Media activists - Street Art, Info, migration rights, anarchism, anti-fascism.. [Spanish, English and French]

Mixed American Life

Mixed Culture | Mixed Heritage | Mixed Identity | Mixed Parenting

Righting Red

Ramblings, ruminations, and activism from an idealistic Lakota storyteller.

The International Anti-Fascist Defence Fund

Real solidarity for those fighting hate.

flightattendantfailures

Documenting White Supremacists Internet Extortion

PEACH STATE ANTI-RACIST-ACTION

Directly Confronting Racism Online and in the Streets!

A Halfbreed's Reasoning

artwork property of Christi Belcourt (http://www.christibelcourt.com)

SIPAZ Blog

Blog of the International Service for Peace

Spirit In Action

Change IS coming. WE can make it GOOD.

DEPRESSION: my muse

Trying to get to a better place.

bayareaintifada

Springboard for News, Updates, Analysis & Action Alerts for 3rd World Liberation & Decolonization from the Bay Area & Beyond

murrjw

murrjw

Red and Black Britain

An anarchists voice

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 14,343 other followers