Who is responsible for death threats from a Twitter bot?

So who is responsible? I can’t claim familiarity with Dutch law (although I’m assuming tulips have special rights), but I’ve argued before that in the United States the First Amendment protection of free speech extends to robots—including bots. It would be unconstitutional for American police to require van der Goot to shut down the bot if its speech qualified as constitutionally protected speech.

“True threats” are not protected under the First Amendment, and the Amsterdam police certainly considered the bot’s tweet just that. But it’s hard to say whether the tweet expressed sufficient “intent to intimidate” to qualify as a true threat without having more information about the tweet, the bot, and the circumstances around it. In Virginia v. Black, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the government “may choose to prohibit only those forms of intimidation that are most likely to inspire fear of bodily harm.” If the bot’s tweet was not reasonably likely to inspire fear of bodily harm given all of the facts, the Constitution would have prohibited police efforts to delete it, even though it’s not a person. If the bot’s tweet falls within constitutionally protected speech, no one would have had criminal responsibility because there would be no crime.

via Who is responsible for death threats from a Twitter bot?.

Doña Dulcinea

The Sun Shines Behind The Clouds Through The Raindrops Falling On My Head

Socialist Action

In Solidarity With Workers and the Oppressed Everywhere

Richardson Reports

News you can't get anywhere else....


The News That Matters about the Nuclear Industry Fukushima Chernobyl Mayak Three Mile Island Atomic Testing Radiation Isotope

AGR Daily News

Quaker Inspired, Evidence Based, Art And Science Of Sustainable Health Plus Success - How To Create Heaven On Earth - Education For Seventh Generation Rainbow Warriors


People and Trends


Louise Mensch, National Security Journalism

Angry White Men

Tracking White Supremacy

Tina Ngata

Dismantling Frameworks of Domination, Rematriating Ways of Being.


News, politics, insights, inside information from the left

Mike Rothschild

Conspiracy theory researcher and debunker

caged but undaunted

stanley l cohen


We are a group of grassroots activists from all over the world. Palestine Unites Us. News about Palestine and its supporters worldwide

settler colonial studies blog

A blog for the advancement of settler colonial studies


The best longform stories on the web

%d bloggers like this: